Is atheism irrational? A philosopher says “yes”

Pues el debate no está tan difícil de entender, y por lo tanto, se puede ver desde la crítica aquí publicada, que hay quienes tratan de solamente mantener el debate en vigencia, sin importar que se propongan ideas tan contradictorias como que el ateísmo se basa en la fe, igual que una religión, pues levanta sosèchas sobre quienes afirman tal cosa. Sospechas de ser manipuladores de la información, y/o, sopechas de ser unos ignorantes ilustrados, con título de “apantallapendejos”.

Why Evolution Is True

Over at The Atlantic, you can read one of the more bizarre takes on atheism I’ve seen in a while. It’s not a nasty critique of New Atheism in the John Gray style, but a very strange piece about how New Atheism, LIKE RELIGION (these articles always draw that parallel), is based on wish-thinking.

“What?”, you say. “How can that be?” Well, read “Irrational Atheism,” a short piece by Crispin Sartwell, a philosophy professor at Dickinson College in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, and, according to Wikipedia, “a self-described individualist anarchist.” If you don’t know what that is, Wikipedia can also inform you about individualist anarchism.

At any rate, I find it bizarre that so many of these misguided pieces—articles that nearly all of us could refute standing on our heads, come from philosophy professors. What does that say about philosophy?

Sartwell’s piece starts off on a bad note:

Religious beliefs are remarkably various. But sometimes…

Ver la entrada original 2.166 palabras más


North Carolina diner drops religious discount

Why Evolution Is True

Well, things often move fast when the Freedom from Religion Foundation (FFRF) complains about First Amendment violations. Just yesterday I wrote about how Mary’s Gourmet Diner in Winston-Salem, North Carolina was giving customers a 15% food discount for praying aloud in their restaurant. I also posted a letter that FFRF attorney Elizabeth Cavell wrote to the diner telling them that they were violating the Civil Rights Act by discriminating among customers on the basis of religion.  In the end, it took Mary Haglund, the owner, just one day to “see the light.” I quote from a Freedom from Religion Foundation bulletin:

Mary’s Gourmet Diner agrees with the Freedom From Religion Foundation that all of its customers should be treated equally instead of some being rewarded for praying in the restaurant in Winston-Salem, N.C.

Staff Attorney Elizabeth Cavell wrote an Aug. 4 letter of complaint after FFRF, a national state-church watchdog, learned that the diner had long…

Ver la entrada original 548 palabras más

Creationist Dembski gives academic talk at MY university!

Why Evolution Is True

An outraged alumnus of the University of Chicago called my attention to an upcoming “Computations in Science” Seminar. It is being given by none other than intelligent-design creationist William Dembski, famous for his characterization of ID in Touchstone Magazine:

Intelligent design is just the Logos theology of John’s Gospel restated in the idiom of information theory.

And now he’s coming here to talk about this?

Screen Shot 2014-08-08 at 9.51.40 AM

So Dembski is going to come here and talk to a bunch of computational scientists about how evolution can’t be right because of his No Free Lunch Theorem, which has already been debunked (see here. here, and here for the debunking). I can’t believe that my own university, proud of its reputation and academic rigor, is presenting creationism as serious science. As my correspondent noted: “WTF is happening at my alma mater?”

University of Chicago, and especially those responsible for inviting speakers to…

Ver la entrada original 44 palabras más